LIFO usually produces a lower gross profit than FIFO only because the costs of the goods purchased or produced have been increasing over the past decades. Since LIFO assigns the latest costs of the goods purchased or produced to the cost of goods sold, the rising costs mean a higher amount of cost of goods sold on the income statement. That in turn means a lower gross profit than assigning the first or oldest costs to the cost of goods sold under FIFO.
If costs were to steadily decrease over several years, LIFO would result in a higher gross profit than FIFO. The reason is that LIFO would be assigning the latest costs (which will be lower costs than the first or oldest costs) to the cost of goods sold on the income statement. That in turn means a higher gross profit than under the FIFO cost flow assumption.
