Accounting


Accounting Forum

AccountingCoach.com is the world's largest free online accounting course.


Not signed in (Sign In)

Categories

Vanilla 1.1.7 is a product of Lussumo. More Information: Documentation, Community Support.

Welcome Guest!
Want to take part in these discussions? If you have an account, sign in now.
If you don't have an account, apply for one now.
    • CommentAuthornlia11
    • CommentTimeJun 8th 2007
     
    Hello all!

    How would you go about recording the disposal of a fixed asset in the form of a donation. The assets was donated to another company. Obviously there would be a credit to the fixed asset, but what would be debited? There is no accumulated depreciation because the asset was donated at the end of last year. So there would be a debit to depreciation expense for the current year (2006) but where would the remainder of the debit go to?

    Thanks in advance!
    • CommentAuthormacc2101
    • CommentTimeJun 20th 2007
     
    Let me ask you. Why would you make another debit to depreciation expense in 2006 if you donated it the year before?. I believe you would have to get this off the books in the year you donated it. I believe crediting good will, but you cannot write off more that what you have it valued at. If after depreciation your equipment is worth 75.00 that is what you are taking off the books.
    • CommentAuthordj36
    • CommentTimeJun 22nd 2007
     
    The asset should have been removed the previous year. I am assuming that the prior year books are closed and unchangeable. It sounds like the asset was inadvertently left on the books and depreciated each month this year. In this case I would give the disposal date as 01/01/06 and correct the deprecation expense you have incurred so far this year. You should note this to your auditors. If the asset value is large enough, it may required different treatment.

    Why isn't there accumulated depreciation? Accumulated Depreciation should not be closed out for an asset until the asset is removed from the books.

    I believe the entry should be:

    Debit Accum Depr
    Debit Loss on Donated Asset
    Credit Depr Exp (for 2006 depr)
    Credit Fixed Asset

    You would not credit Goodwill.
    • CommentAuthorabril
    • CommentTimeJun 30th 2007
     
    im confused, why was expense credited? the company who recieved will have to deal with that and not the one who donated the assets and why was goodwill involved in here? goodwill is accounted for in a different manner.

    "There is no accumulated depreciation because the asset was donated at the end of last year."

    when you dispose or donate it, the entry is simply this..

    dr> accum. depreciation
    dr> loss on disposal of fixed asset
    cr> fixed asset

    obviously, you will gain nothing from donating so whatever's left to the value of your fixed asset (you call it carrying value), is your loss.

    "So there would be a debit to depreciation expense for the current year (2006) but where would the remainder of the debit go to?"

    there would be no more depreciation expense for the current year because you have just disposed the asset last year.
  1.  
    abril;

    Here is why dj36 noted a credit to Depreciation Expense.

    In the original question, the asker stated that the equipment was donated in 2005, we know this because he stated there was no accumulated depreciation in 2006 because the item was donated the year prior, yet the asker noted that there was depreciation expense recorded for 2006. Since the item was donated the year prior, it should have been written off the books that same year. To do that Accumulated Depreciation would be debited and Equipment would be credited, the difference between the two (since this is a donation) would be the loss and credited as such. If they inadvertently recorded depreciation expense in 2006, it has to be removed and therefore must be put in as a credit. This is why dj36 credited Depreciation Expense, to remove the amount debited to the expense account in 2006.



 

Why AccountingCoach.com?

the accounting coach

AccountingCoach.com is designed to help people without an accounting background easily understand accounting concepts at no cost.


By investing thousands of hours, we have created clear and concise accounting information for both business people and students of all ages.


We understand how difficult accounting can be. That's why we have ensured that each accounting topic includes a clear explanation, reinforcing drills, Q&A, puzzles, dictionary of terms, etc.


Read 1,440 Visitor Testimonials



What's on AccountingCoach.com?